How the Roth Conversion works
We compare the after-tax value of converting to a Roth now (paying tax today, then growing tax-free) versus leaving the money in a traditional account (growing now, taxed at withdrawal).
Step by step
- Roth path: subtract today's tax from the amount, then grow it tax-free for the holding period.
- Traditional path: grow the full amount, then subtract the expected future tax rate at withdrawal.
- The difference between the two after-tax values is the Roth advantage (or disadvantage).
The math
roth = amount × (1 − taxNow) × (1+g)^years; traditional = amount × (1+g)^years × (1 − taxLater); benefit = roth − traditional.
Sources & assumptions
- Standard after-tax future-value comparison (public domain).
Note: Nothing proprietary — simplified model (no state tax, IRMAA, or pay-the-tax-from-outside-funds effects).
- This is an educational comparison, not tax advice. Conversions are taxable events.
- It ignores state taxes, IRMAA, and the source of funds used to pay the tax. Consult your advisor and tax professional.